USCIS Proposes to Drop Deference on Extension Petitions

USCIS has proposed ending deference to prior approvals on Form I-129 extensions. Nothing changes yet. Comments close November 13, 2026.

People walk among many American flags displayed on a grassy hill under a cloudy sky.

Employers extending an O-1, H-1B, L-1, or other Form I-129 worker may soon get less help from an earlier approval. USCIS has proposed ending the rule that tells officers to defer to it. Nothing changes yet, and comments are open until November 13, 2026.

On October 14, 2026, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services published a proposal to remove 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). Under that regulation, when the same parties file again on the same facts, officers generally defer to the earlier approval. Comments can be submitted on docket USCIS-2026-0529 through November 13, 2026. Until a final rule comes out, the current regulation stays in place.

What does the current rule require?

Today, an officer reviewing an extension generally accepts the earlier finding that the worker qualified for the classification. To depart from it, the officer needs a material error, a material change, or new material information that hurts eligibility.

This matters most when an employer extends the same worker in the same classification. The proposed rule covers extensions of stay filed on Form I-129, including for O-1, H-1B, L-1, E-1, and E-2 workers.

What would change if the proposal becomes final?

The change would apply to every request filed on Form I-129, not just extensions. Officers could still look at an earlier approval, but they would no longer start from a position of deference to it. Each filing would stand on its own record, and the employer would need to show the worker is still eligible. DHS ties the proposal to the statute, which it reads as placing the burden of proving eligibility on the petitioner, applicant, or beneficiary.

DHS expects officers to look more closely at each request. Its cost estimate predicts more requests for evidence on extensions, so petitioners would spend more time gathering documents and keeping a fuller record of the earlier approval and the worker's continued eligibility. That is DHS's own prediction. When the agency compared past years with and without deference, it found that denial rates did not statistically differ.

For how the classification works and what an O-1 case requires, see the O-1 visa overview from North America Immigration Law Group (WeGreened).